Starr Struck
  • HOME
  • BLOG
  • ABOUT
    • About Me
    • Press
  • ART + DESIGN
    • Design Studio
    • Art Studio
  • YOGA
    • Class Schedule
    • Audio Yoga Classes
    • eBook for Yoga Teachers
    • Playlists
  • CONSULTING
  • SHOP
  • PODCASTS
    • Starr Struck Radio
    • Built on Cape Cod
  • CONTACT

To William J. Broad: It's Time to Pack it Up and Head Home...You're Done Here.

2/28/2012

 
Picture
Mr. Broad, in all his yoga-hating glory ;)
As if he hadn't already done enough PR damage to yoga with "How Yoga Can Wreck Your Body" and the subsequent book that has now been released, William J. Broad has released yet another scathing yoga review in The New York Times--and this one, amazingly-enough, makes me even more upset than the first. The title? "Yoga and Sex Scandals: No Surprise Here." 

What I want to say is this--Mr. Broad, why do you have such a vendetta against yoga? And why are you writing such misinformed articles for the NYT?  On the other hand, NYT, why aren't you doing a better job editing and fact-checking this guy? Why are you supporting such sensational journalism? And how can you publish the sentence "But perhaps — if students and teachers knew more about what Hatha can do, and what it was designed to do — they would find themselves less prone to surprise and unyogalike distress." ????

Um, what!?!?!?! Hatha yoga was designed as a way to "hasten rapturous [sexual] bliss???" And the "discipline began as a sex cult???" Nope. Just no. Mr Broad, I know that you're prone to exaggeration, but I have to tell you that you are just incorrect here.  

Picture
Yep, definitely a sex cult. (Image via flowhoodriver.com)
I'll save you all from reading my entire imaginary reply to Broad (as if he would ever care what a lowly, "sex-cult"-participant thinks!), and instead, just want to set the record straight for my readers (and for my Grandmother, who undoubtedly will read the article, just as she did last time, and begin worrying about me...): last year, I spent an entire day learning about Tantra Philosophy. I'm no expert (at all!), and would never purport to be, but  during this weekend I learned that Hatha Yoga stemmed from both Tantra and Samkhya philosophy, and that neither of these philosophies started out having anything to do with sex-cults. Tantra has gotten associated with sexual practices along the way because people love a good sex scandal, and because part of the original Tantra movement was to deliberately violate the "no-no's" of the tradition at the time, and of course, one of those no-nos was sexual contact (there were many others, but they haven't been  as highly publicized). 

Some even believe that Tantra rose as a sort of political revolution, trying to shake things up a bit (for instance, what will happen if you eat meat or drink wine, even though we're not supposed to?). But it did not start as a sex-cult and true Tantra is still not about sex, it's image has just gotten very twisted by our sex-obsessed culture. But the other thing is this--Hatha Yoga as we know it today, in the west, is NOTHING like what it was thousands of years ago, so it doesn't really matter. Also, as a sidenote, both Bhuddism and Hinduism grew out of Tantra philosophy, and no one is calling them religions based solely on sex, right?

As for Broad's point about all of the gurus and founders of various yoga practices being corrupt sexual "philanderers," I'd like to argue that this stems not from the practice of yoga and the "pelvic regions [that] feel more sensitive and orgasms more intense," but instead, from the effects of good old power, money, and fame. I think that these gurus, founders, and leaders are falling prey to the exact same power-trip that movie stars, politicians,  and CEOs fall prey to--only politicians aren't always surrounded by 100's of beautiful, healthy women in tight clothes, so their philandering may not be as widespread or systemic. I completely agree that there has been an abuse of power in the yoga community (and especially recently, with the John Friend scandal), but I don't think that the practice of yoga is to blame--it's the individuals who gain power and prestige who are at the root of the problem.

So there you have it. To summarize, yes, I've seen the article, and no, I don't agree with it. 

And to all of the blog-reading Grandmothers out there--no, yoga is NOT a sex-cult.

Namaste!
Mary Catherine

Andrew Simpson
2/28/2012 08:22:30 am

He seems to be on a mission to discredit yoga as much as possible. Way to give it to him MC!

Peter Tarsio link
3/5/2012 05:56:30 am

I have to say that I began to read Broads book the Science of Yoga and I find his claims and accusations are inaccurate let alone misleading. If he really thought about what he was doing himself in regard to his own relationship with yoga, which by the way he blames for his back injury but then to go on and make things up that just ain't true is a form of yellow journalism directed at something that he knows little about. How is it possible that he didn't cite Georg Feuerstein and read up on the subject and do years of research before ascribing all this nonsense about yoga. Yes, we know some of the gurus and swamis did cross the line and as you said power,money and fame are the problem. So what if yoga enhances your pleasure as if that were a sin or some kind of taboo. I mean to say Mr. Broad is just trying to sell his books and draw attention to himself as if he were some kind of authority who has the low down on the pros and cons of yoga. Bah hum bug to that.
Pt


Comments are closed.
    Picture
    Picture

    HELLO!

    I'm Mary Catherine, a Cape Cod-based yoga teacher, painter, designer, writer, mom, and list-maker extraordinaire. My goal is to inspire you to start living a more creative, simple, joyful, + purposeful life. 
    {Learn more + read my story}
    Picture


    FOLLOW


    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    NEW READER?

    START HERE
    Picture

    HOW TO EARN A LIVING TEACHING YOGA eBOOK


    Picture
    Picture

    THE PODCAST


    Picture
    Picture

    REGULAR COLUMNS


    Audio Yoga Classes
    L​ove This! 
    Mat Matters
    ​
    Motherhood Monthly
    Reading Lists {Seasonal}
    Simple Joys of the Week 
    ​
    Simply Sugarless
    Starr Struck Radio
    Picture

    RECEIVE VIA EMAIL

    NEWSLETTER
    BLOG POSTS
    Picture

    RECENT INSTAS


    Picture

    VISIT MY ETSY SHOP


    Picture

    TOPICS



    A Dress a Day
    Art 
    Blogging
    Book Recommendations
    Clean Creations
    Creativity + DIY
    Etsy Collections
    From the Archives​
    Healthy Lifestyle
    ​Home Improvement
    Life Lessons
    ​Logo Design
    Malebox
    ​
    Motherhood
    Music
    Paintings + Process
    ​Parenting
    Personal Essays
    ​Pregnancy
    Recipes
    Relationships
    Sayde Sundays
    Self-Employment
    Slowing Down
    Snapshots
    Teaching Yoga
    Weddings
    Yoga
    Picture

    JOIN ME


    Retreats
    Workshops
    Podcasts
    eBook
    Consult
    Yoga Videos
    Yoga Class Schedule

WANT MORE STARR STRUCK? Sign up to receive my monthly newsletter + receive a *free* download of my eBook Out of My Mind: Six Years of Starr Struck {A Collection of my favorite blog posts from over the years}:


DISCLOSURE

This blog is a personal blog written and edited by me. From time to time, I accept compensation for sponsored posts and campaigns. However, any sponsored content will be clearly identified as paid or sponsored. Even though I receive compensation for sponsored posts, I always give my honest opinions, findings, beliefs, or experiences on those topics or products. The views and opinions expressed on this blog are purely my own. 

I am also a  participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.
  • HOME
  • BLOG
  • ABOUT
    • About Me
    • Press
  • ART + DESIGN
    • Design Studio
    • Art Studio
  • YOGA
    • Class Schedule
    • Audio Yoga Classes
    • eBook for Yoga Teachers
    • Playlists
  • CONSULTING
  • SHOP
  • PODCASTS
    • Starr Struck Radio
    • Built on Cape Cod
  • CONTACT